Sonia S. Siraz, Björn Claes, and Julio de Castro. Legitimacy in Contested Issue Fields: How Type-Based Validity Cues, Cue Congruence, and Personal Values Shape Propriety. European Management Review.
Our study examines how evaluators form propriety beliefs when they encounter several potentially conflicting validity cues at once. In a conjoint experiment on fracking in France and Spain, we obtained 3,952 evaluations from 247 individuals.
We shift from classifying validity cues by source, distinguishing authorization from endorsement, to classifying them by the type of legitimacy they signal. In the experiment, public opinion served as a normative cue, economic impact as a pragmatic cue, the regulatory setting as a regulatory cue, and venture longevity as a cognitive cue. Economic impact and public opinion had the largest estimated effects on propriety, followed by the regulatory setting and venture longevity. The regulated setting also amplified the effects of the other three cues.
We introduce two concepts to the legitimacy literature. Cue congruence captures the extent to which multiple validity cues point in the same evaluative direction. Consistently favorable cues produced the highest average propriety judgments, and consistently unfavorable cues produced the lowest. When cues conflicted, the average judgment was near the midpoint, but interestingly judgments varied more across evaluators than under any other cue combination. Differences in evaluators’ personal values help explain why the same cues carried different weight. Cue-value congruence captures whether validity cues resonate with or conflict with those values. When judging the propriety of fracking, evaluators with stronger environmental values attributed higher weight to favorable public opinion and less weight to economic impact, regulatory setting, and venture longevity.
In a related Journal of Management Studies paper, Thaler, Sievert, Siraz, and Pinz (2026) examined authorization and endorsement alongside perceived categorical fit, which emerged as the strongest predictor of propriety. Our type-based approach extends that work on validity cues. Our findings on conflicting cues also bring the grey area between legitimacy and illegitimacy to the microlevel, extending the framework we developed with Eero Vaara in Siraz et al. (2023).